census says Where born: ca 1850 NY Married: Helen Elizabeth Hazzard (ca 1852 NY; res: 1900-30 Mt Carmel); res: 1870 Cleveland-Cuyahoga Co OH 1880 Franklin-Warren Co OH Children: - Victoria M (ca 1868 NY m: -
divorced ? Herman; m2: 19 Jun 1909 Jeptha Olin) -
James A* (1870) -
Harry Elvin (21 Sep 1879 OH-26 Nov 1941 bur:Cuyahoga Co OH) -
Howard Leonard (21 Sep 1887 Cleveland OH; res: 1942 Cuyahoga Co OH)