b: OH; d: Petty twp - Lawrence Co IL; d/of Foster Hubbel (1811 OH-1897 IN) & Charlotte Duer (1810-1892 IN); m: John Earnhart (1836-1923 Petty twp); ch: Lewis (1858 OH-1941 IL) & Laura (1863) & Charlotte Elizabeth (1865-1922 CA m: John MacHale) & Martha J (1868-1951 buried Lawrenceville City Cem; m: Hiram A Newell)